My main point I'm trying to make is this: Ms B wasn't just merely 'another teacher I hate'. Every teacher I ever hated always had reason to hate me (I will admit), and there is no such thing as a teacher who treats each and every student like shit. Most teachers I ever hated only disliked certain people, not everyone, or otherwise may have had favourite students. Ms B was the exception, because she didn't hate me and there's a reason why she's leaving at the end of the year (just me complaining wouldn't have been enough for either her to be made redundant/get fired/decide to leave). There is also a reason why her old school's lockers got sprayed with F you Ms B, and for all her school-hopping too.We don't know why she's leaving, but I don't think she got fired, I think Dr H would have found a more creative way to get rid of her, as in the end surely they can't just fire a teacher because students claimed she 'screamed' at them. That's why she only told me I sucked when we were alone in a classroom, because I could never prove all the things she said to me. She was clever enough so that nothing she ever did could fully be interpreted as 'inappropriate' (the closest incident that could have been proven and may have gotten her under the 'fired' radar was probably the yr 11 switching exams issue, and she usually would've been able to think of a better excuse in those types of scenarios as a cover up, rather than simply 'it's good practise for HSC'. She probably had a brain fart on that one rare occasion). In the lecture theatre 10 minutes before a performance, she'd sometimes come up to me in front of everyone and reassure me, tell me I would be fine, when an hour ago when we were all alone she'd have told me my playing sucked. I rather think she got the message after so many people complained about her. Someone arrogant and control-freak like her wouldn't have been able to cope in a school where all the parents and students and other teachers knew everyone complained about her. She needed, after all, to keep herself in control, and you can't control people who no longer are scared of you or think of you as a joke. Heck, too much belonging and
The Crucible, that's why I'm thinking this way. Haha, the permeation of fear facilitated by an individual who wields supreme power may determine the society's need for conformity, and hence belonging, in order to avoid drastic repercussions of alienation.
The day we found out she left (via girls' parents who heard it at a PA meeting), the yr 12's all were so happy. The fact that I was the only year 12 she taught and yet everyone in music 1 hated her, just goes to show that this is not a normal teacher who people merely disliked. The yr 11's were even more happy (because they would have been stuck with her next year). I'm happy for yr 11 violinist (though I don't think violinists would really be on Ms B's victim list, it was more the pianists). After all, the yr 11 girl has serious potential (encore nominee I'm betting), and Ms B would need to have the occasional 'musical genius' to exploit so she could say 'lookie here, our school is good at music'. She just always made sure she never 'nurtured' the pianists. Believe me, when I first came to the school I thought everyone sucked at piano, because I'd never really heard anyone in the lower year groups play anything good for like a whole year. Until I eventually heard some of them play (during the one music festival you could audition for voluntarily) and a few of them were actually quite good. At a regular school they too would have performed at school concerts and such, but because of Ms B's issues, she could never bring herself to acknowledge that there were talented pianists in yr 11 and 10 who did not get the opportunity to perform as they would have if they had been at a school with a good music department. I was the only exception, because technically she was my music extension teacher. When I performed, it looked good for her, because I was her 'student', and especially when I performed the ensemble piece at the big school concert, it looked like she had 'helped us rehearse' even though she had only been present at one rehearsal.
There was a reason why she never let any of us pianists perform solos, and at first when Rh brought up the 'insecure jealousy' thing, I thought 'yeah right' and actually thought she was crazy. Until I realised, and it made me feel better. I was never the type to ever get egotistical about piano, because of my own piano teacher and her strict ways (it is very hard to be egotistical when you have for years been compared every week to other students who are always better than you). Funnily enough, it was my own piano teacher who confirmed Rh's theory. Ms B was jealous. Of me, of my piano teacher's abilities, of Ms V's, and she was insecure about how the talented junior pianists would turn out by the time they got around to doing HSC music extension. I say this in the least egotistical way possible, but it is the truth. And as soon as Rh and my piano teacher helped me realise this, I no longer was affected as much by the negativity, or thought of my playing and hours and hours and hours of practice as futile and a failure. Then the performance anxiety would almost completely disappear, because Ms B had previously succeeded in making her own insecurities mine. And when you just get up on that stage, confident, knowing that you have done hours of practice, knowing that no one else has the right to judge, and your mind isn't full of Ms B's negativity, then the sweaty hands and dry mouth pretty much disappear. Ironically, my confidence as a performer also developed thanks to Ms B. It took the realisation of why Ms B loved hurting me intentionally, and it took me seeing it as a compliment that Ms B felt threatened by me and my piano teacher, to get rid of the performance anxiety. By the time of my last performance in front of the entire school, Ms B was no longer teaching me and my piano teacher, too, was no longer teaching me (though it had been a couple of years since my piano teacher had last made me feel like a failure, and my piano teacher was only doing this to get me to practise, not because she was a psychopath). Getting rid of the negativity and self-doubt these external forces could inflict upon me, and realising that Ms B and my piano teacher don't deserve my respect. I don't admire their ways of teaching, I don't admire them as people. Their opinions used to mean everything to me (in terms of my playing). I believed every word, and now I realise just because they are teachers, doesn't mean they were correct or deserved my respect. C deserves my respect. C proves her knowledge, doesn't pretend to know what she doesn't know. C tells me what I'm doing wrong and gives me creative ideas to fix it. The best thing about C? She always knew how much practice I did. Because no matter how many compliments or constructive criticisms C gave me, she would acknowledge those hours of practice regardless. Most importantly, C gave me a reason to keep playing, have the motivation to practise when my whole life I've had this whole huge struggle with this thing I am most insecure about, always doubting myself about. I never had the passion, I've always thought. Never was a musical genius, never enjoyed practising. According to C, there is no such thing as musical talent. You are born with genes that determine where your future passions may lie. And talent is basically what you make of the things you are passionate at. And C made a good point. Things like procrastination, she said no matter how much you make your brain do something, as long as your subconscious mind gives your conscious mind a reason not to do it, then your brain won't do it, and it's all about getting to the heart of why you inevitably will do/won't do something. And just like with procrastination, C reckons that if I wasn't passionate about piano, I would have quit long ago like all those other kids. That somehow, my subconscious mind would have given my conscious mind a strong enough reason to discontinue, to the point where no matter how much a parent pushes their child, the child will inevitably quit. Just like no matter how much I try and stop procrastinating, I inevitably procrastinate. What I'm still trying to figure out is how my subconscious mind is passionate about music and piano, even though my conscious mind denies this and blocks it out. C thinks it would be a shame if I didn't do it at uni. Maybe I can do it after all without feeling like an idiot amidst super-passionate musicians. She even thinks I have really unusually soft
pianissimos which are a sign that someone is really musical.
Really musical. I'd like to think she wasn't just saying it to make me feel better the day before my exam, but she isn't that type anyway, she's honest. I think 'musical' is what every musician wants to be labelled as. It's the highest compliment, I think. Not 'talented', not 'oh wow your hands can move so fast', not 'skilled' or 'proficient' or 'highly advanced', but 'musical', and I never expected someone to ever think of me in that way. 'Musical' is the best compliment anyone has ever given to me. It took awhile of coaxing (because I always find it awkward to play emotionally in front of people I know I'll see again. In front of examiners, I give it my most heart-wrenching performance haha because I know I'll never have to see them again). But B my cellist and C and even the violinist who I still don't know the name of, encouraged me to repeat the opening of that piano trio over and over until I could picture a funeral procession in my head. I then played that piece without picturing anything. Blankness. I wish I could say I felt the sadness of the music, but my head was like in another stratosphere. I wasn't thinking anything, but at the same time I was highly aware of the balance between the piano, the cello and the violin. And after that, C told me it was the best I'd ever played. That it made her think of her best friend at music college in London who'd died in a car crash when she was still young, and it made her feel all the anger and frustration, but all the beauty and passion too. I think that's the most amazing thing anyone has ever told me (heck that almost made me cry). B said she could really feel me feeling the music too, and that I was aware of both her and the violinist playing, even when I told them my mind was just blank. Then B my cellist thought maybe I felt emotions abstractly or something. Too confusing too go into.
And to this day I still can't say whether I truly enjoy piano, even though I've done it for 13 years. It's a bit like a cross between brushing my teeth, going jogging for 30 minutes, and doing the laundry (this doesn't make sense even to me). But at the same time, brushing your teeth, though so routine-like, makes you feel clean. Doing the laundry, stupidly enough, makes me feel like I've accomplished something, that satisfaction of completing a piece of menial housework. Going jogging releases endorphins and you feel like you've just done something good for your body, even when you're exhausted. A combination of that all that is what piano is like to me. Mental exhaustion coupled with occasional flashes of clarity when you play something nicely and then sudden surges of motivation and satisfaction when you get those certain hours completed, then back to mental exhaustion until it becomes daily routine. I can't imagine quitting it, though I don't even enjoy it either. But it's weird, like an old habit I have to keep. As soon as my HSC was done and over with, the first thing I did when I got home was choose some Lmus pieces to learn (just so I could maintain finger dexterity, I told myself, and improve sightreading). I don't know what I will do with piano, or if I will study it at uni, or whether I even want to. I just want to figure this out eventually. I do really enjoy piano accompaniment though. I actually love accompanying people for some weird reason. I love that feeling of making music with someone else, of leading someone or having someone lead me into the music, of keeping the background rhythm whilst a vocalist does her thing. How you're not alone on stage vulnerable in front of the audience, but it's almost the opposite...when I'm with someone else, I enter a world with them and I can block out everyone outside in the audience. We do out own thing and ignore the audience, whereas I can rarely do that with a solo. I always play my best when I am accompanying someone else. I think the thing I most love about piano accompaniment is that sense of awareness...it's hard to explain, but soon enough, after a certain amount of recordings listened to or rehearsals, you kind of subconsciously blend with the soloist. Your brain automatically picks up on their signals, knows when they are coming in, until you can even tell what type of emotion they are trying to portray. You are aware of them somewhere in the back of your mind, and yet wholly unaware of anything at all in the forefront of your mind, and your own playing just somehow blends in with theirs by its own. This is so much bull I don't even understand what I'm writing, it's hard to explain.
Piano is my personal thing. What I make of it is up to me. I still don't understand it yet. I still don't feel that connection I felt when I was 11 and the most upset I'd ever been in my life. According to C, we often play more beautifully when we are especially sad or happy. That's why it became my outlet when I was 11 and that's when I enjoyed it most, and after that things were just numb and I was neither sad nor happy and so my playing came out sounding dull, too. The more life experiences we have, the more we come to appreciate piano playing and the more we can connect with the instrument emotionally. All those composers I played...Schubert, Chopin, Liszt, Schumann..I could go on...all of them had tragic experiences. According to C, Chopin only ever composed for piano, and it was like his 'blankie' because he never left it his entire life. It was his outlet after his family was murdered and he fled as a refugee to Paris. Hard to imagine, yet he can compose the most beautiful and heart-wrenching melodies. I tried to picture Chopin's family dead when I performed that nocturne, but it's hard, because I'm still a teenager and nothing that tragic has happened to me yet. Apparently if I leave some of these pieces for now and come back to them in say 10 years time, I perceive them differently and gain new appreciation for them (incidentally my piano teacher also said the exact same thing as C: just as you perceive a book differently when you read it 10 years later, so do you perceive the music). That's what B my cellist said, too (and she was an incredible cellist, gave me goosebumps even when I was playing with her). She's auditioning for the sydney symphony and I guarantee you one day she will be principal cellist in that orchestra. It's incredible, because she got into the con and has done her masters and has got all her diplomas, yet she only started cello when she was 13!
No one can tell me I suck, or that I am shocking, or that I play with no emotion. If I wasn't nervous, then I would be able to connect with the music. F anyone who judges my playing, unless they can get up there and show me how it's 'meant' to be done. I worked hard to get to where I am with piano, and even if someone else in the audience has done so too, so what? That's their journey. On stage I can spill out and express the finished product of all the suffering. That is the answer to getting rid of performance anxiety, and that's what I did on the last day of school. Not a single drop of nervous sweat. I even hugged Rh afterwards and was all smiles in front of everyone on stage. I'm proud of myself, because a year ago, under Ms B, I would never even have agreed to perform in front of the whole school. And back in year 7, when my piano teacher terrorised me every lesson, my hands would have been shaking. It's been good for me, a learning experience, and it's a shame it took me my last performance before I could understand performance anxiety to the fullest.
The funniest thing? All the other music teachers were so relieved when they knew Ms B was leaving, you could tell. Mr L, for once, actually didn't take forever to get a sentence out when asked questions about assessments (previously feared he'd give us the wrong info, because he did that once and Ms B gave it to him big time). Ms V and Ms F were actually all of a sudden 3 x nicer to me (they would've heard about me not wanting Ms B as my teacher, as the day after I complained Ms H interviewed the entire music department and even Mr L told me 'something big was getting sorted out', when he normally wouldn't have dared).
They say what doesn't kill you makes you stronger. And I think the experience with Ms B certainly made me stronger. Because there are psychopaths out there in the world and in the workforce, and I'm only grateful I came across one and now know what to look out for. Better I had this experience in high school, where the student always has the ultimate power to complain, than at a workforce with a psychopath as my boss and no one to help me. And then I start to think, is it really Ms B's fault? This is when I'm in danger of getting philosophical and saying 1000 more words about the topic at hand. Are people born psychopaths, or are psychopathic tendencies developed? Is Ms B to blame? Is it just because she doesn't have kids, and can't think to herself (because she is my mum's exact age), 'How would I feel if a teacher treated
my daughter this way?'. It's confusing. I don't hate her exactly, because she never hated me. And all the stuff she did to me, what if she couldn't help it? She has school-hopped enough times now for me to know that she never, ever acknowledges herself as being in the wrong. Sometimes I almost feel pity, because what childhood must she have had, when no other teacher has made me bawl my eyes out at school? Is she just going to live the rest of her life with her crazy carbon-tax-doesn't-exist husband, and just be this way for like the next 50 years? What I mainly wish I knew is whether no one is in the blame here, if I have the right to hate her. The frustrating nature vs nurture that I won't go into.
I'm betting my next post will be about my piano teacher or something, super-influential life figure number 2. I can bullshit so much about life.